The rivalry that defines college football in the state got its start 118 years ago with Territorial Normal School's win over UofA
When Sun Devil football players hoisted the Territorial Cup on Nov. 25 after defeating their in-state rival, the University of Arizona Wildcats, there was an imposter in their midst.
All the players who touched the cup were on the roster; all the coaches who cheered the victory were actively employed (at the time).
No, the imposter was the cup itself.
The trophy that got its fair share of kisses from the team after the victory is a replica, used to protect the 118-year-old original from the chaos of celebratory revelry.
This year, the actual transfer of the silver chalice from UofA to ASU took place six days after the win, and the ASU official in charge of obtaining it and bringing up Interstate 10 from Tucson is university archivist Rob Spindler.
“This has been one of the most fun things that I have done in my 29 years here at Arizona State University,” Spindler said of being the caretaker of the cup in the years it has lived in the Luhrs Reading Room at Hayden Library. “And it’s a great honor and privilege to defend and maintain this tradition on behalf of our great Sun Devil football teams and Arizona State University.”
That tradition dates back to the days before the Wildcats were in-state rivals — because the state of Arizona did not yet exist.
The cup was first awarded to the Territorial Normal School, the original name of the school known now as ASU. The year was 1899, and in the course of a season the Normal School defeated not only the University of Arizona, but others in a league that included the Phoenix Union High School and the Phoenix Indian School.
The Arizona Republican — what The Arizona Republic newspaper was called at the time — described the Normal School’s win over UofA as a victory of brawn over brain.
“The University boys showed the most skill and science, but they lacked the physical strength and endurance,” the paper reported. “The two teams placed in a balance, the Normals would have weighted at least a third more than the University’s. Weight tells in a football contest.”
It was that victory that earned the Normal School the prize of the original Territorial Cup, purchased, according to Spindler, from a manufacturer called Reed and Barton out of Taunton, Massachusetts. It cost $20 at the time — roughly equivalent to $500 now.
It was presented to the team in January 1900. Soon after, it disappeared for more than 80 years, only to turn up in a closet in the First Congregational Church of Tempe in 1983. It was returned to ASU’s possession.
In 2001, then-ASU President Lattie Coor and then-UofA President Peter Likins signed what was called the “Territorial Cup Protocol,” devising the system that stands today, in which the winner of the annual match up takes home the original trophy to display.
This year, Spindler drove down to UofA to meet with his counterparts, the Wildcat caretakers of the trophy, the Friday following the victory.
The cup travels in a hard-sided case with both ASU and UofA luggage tags attached, a testament to the friendly rivalry, and the fascinating backstory behind a piece of Arizona history.
Think you know your ASU history? Take our quiz! (Click to the next photo for the answer).
Question: What was the original mascot of the Territorial Normal School football team?Photo from ASU Library archives
Answer: The Owls.Photo from ASU Library archives
Question: In what league did the Territorial Normal School football team play during the 1899 season?Photo courtesy of Arizona Board of Regents
Answer: The Arizona Foot Ball League of 1899, which was made up of four teams: Phoenix Union High School, Phoenix Indian School, the Territorial Normal School and the University of Arizona. As far as is known, the league only lasted one season, and the Normal School was awarded the cup after winning three games.Photo courtesy of Arizona Board of Regents
Question: Where was the Territorial Cup found after disappearing for 83 years?Photo illustration
Answer: On a shelf in a closet of the First Congregational Church of Tempe.Photo by Tony the Marine [CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0), via Wikimedia Commons
Question: Where does the Territorial Cup reside when it is back home in Tempe?Photo by Ken Fagan/ASU Now
Answer: The Luhrs Reading Room at Hayden Library on the Tempe campus.Photo by Ken Fagan/ASU Now