Challenge accepted: Leveling the playing field in science education

ASU receives $1 million to create more inclusive science program


June 20, 2018

In college, science is often seen as an exclusive field — one reserved only for exceptionally bright students. And for decades, academic leaders in higher education have used introductory science courses to “weed out” the so-called “unqualified” students. 

But the rules are changing, and the playing field is leveling out. Undergraduate biology classroom ASU will receive $1 million from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute to create a more inclusive science program. Download Full Image

Arizona State University, along with 56 other schools, will receive $1 million in grant support over five years from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute (HHMI) to engage in a process of culture change and work toward including all students in science learning, regardless of background.

“We know that student success is tied closely to feeling included in the scholarly life of ASU,” said James P. Collins, a professor with the School of Life Sciences and the lead investigator for the grant. “Our aim is to transition students from high school thinking to university thinking by creating a culture of inclusion. This will help students develop critical-thinking skills focused on ‘big picture’ questions rather than simple, test-driven content mastery.”

Each participating university will launch its own program to support the institute’s “Inclusive Excellence” initiative, which aims to catalyze schools’ efforts to include all students in science, especially underrepresented ethnic minorities, first-generation college students and working adults with families. 

ASU will begin by working with a diverse group of science faculty members to create a series of digital learning modules. These online tools, called “Exploration Experiences,” will be built around each faculty member’s research area and will serve curricular and developmental goals for first-year students. All first-year students in the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences will be required to use these modules during ASU 101, a required course for new students.

“This means that the impact of this program will be at scale — creating a place for all of our new students to reflect on what college entails and a metacognitive understanding of the types of discovery that will happen in each of their specific majors,” said Paul LePore, associate dean of student and academic programs at the college.

“For the thousands of high school students exploring what majors might be right for them, this program will let them take a deep dive into the wide range of majors our college has to offer. In no small way, these efforts will offer prospective students and their families an unparalleled recruiting tool — accelerating the transition that successful students must make from just attending ASU to becoming members of the dynamic learning communities that exist within each of our undergraduate programs,” he added.

Biology laboratory course

With this grant, ASU will develop new, online learning modules that will allow students to explore majors and develop critical thinking skills. Photo by Sandra Leander/ASU

Although ASU is well-known as a leader in enrolling diverse and underserved student populations, one area where Collins and his team believe improvements can be made is in ensuring that these students succeed in their college experience. The team aims to help faculty members embrace a more inclusive style of teaching, where instructors understand their responsibility to help diverse students succeed. 

By teaching faculty members how to use new technologies that foster interactivity and adaptivity to student needs, they will be empowered to build experiences that meet students at their own learning levels and tutor them to succeed at their own pace. 

Ariel Anbar, a professor with ASU’s School of Earth and Space Exploration, said: “The education technology revolution is creating powerful new ways to draw new students into the diversity of people, thought, experience and opportunity available at a research university like ASU. Finding a way to do that early is important for everyone, and especially for students who are the first in their families to go to college.” Anbar, director of the Center for Education Through eXploration at ASU, will lead the development of the Exploration Experiences.

Sara Brownell, a biology education researcher and associate professor with the School of Life Sciences, will be the lead for assessing the impact of the program.

“We hope to collect data to help us make evidence-based decisions about how to make our undergraduate science programs more inclusive,” Brownell said.

Each participating school will work with HHMI and the Association of American Colleges and Universities to evaluate progress and refine approaches as necessary. In addition, the grantees will learn from each other by working in clusters of four to five schools. Ultimately, HHMI hopes the schools will discover strategies for making meaningful and lasting change that can be adopted by other institutions.

Sandra Leander

Assistant Director of Media Relations, ASU Knowledge Enterprise

480-965-9865

ASU alumna shares career insights


June 19, 2018

Arizona State University political science PhD graduates are employed both in a range of professions and more traditionally as professors at universities all over the globe.

Lisa-Mari Centeno, who graduated with her PhD from the School of Politics and Global Studies in 2003, has made her impact at Adams State University in Colorado. She is currently the only Latina full professor for her university, which is designated as a Hispanic Serving Institution. Centeno also advises an internationally award winning model U.N. team and is the university's women’s and gender studies director. Lisa-Mari Centeno Lisa-Mari Centeno, ASU PhD alumna, teaches political science at Adams State University in Colorado. Download Full Image

Here, Centeno shares some takeaways from her career in academia thus far.

Question: Adams State University was Colorado’s first higher education institution to be designated as a Hispanic Serving Institution. What has your experience as a professor of political science there been like?

Answer: It was very important for me to serve at a Hispanic Serving Institution (HSI) because I was the only Latina in both my undergraduate and graduate poli-sci courses; so I consider myself very fortunate to have been granted a position at Adams State University, the other ASU.

There is, of course, no single Latino culture, but many that overlap one another. The Latino culture of the San Luis Valley is a new layer that I, as a Venezuelan-American, find familiar, but with its own nuances. This is to say that just being categorized as “Hispanic” does not mean one will automatically understand what it means to be at an HSI. At least for me, there was a learning curve.

Although Adams State is an HSI, in a larger sense, I would say that we are a USI: Underserved/Underrepresented Serving Institution. Many of our students, of whatever ethnicity, are first-generation, from low-income backgrounds. Adams State provides an opportunity for those who might not otherwise be able to obtain a college education. This is a source of pride for us.

I chair the LatinX Faculty and Staff Caucus, and one of our ongoing campaigns is greater recruitment of talented Latino/a faculty and administrative staff. It is important for our Latina/o students — but really for all students — to see examples of Latina/o success. On the first day of each semester, I always share with my students that I was a first-generation student from a poor, immigrant family.  My hope is that they will think, “Well if she can do it, I certainly can.”

Q: What does being an advisor for the university’s model U.N. team entail? How have you noticed an impact to students who have participated?

A: Model United Nations is the very best part of my job. With the support of the university and the enthusiasm of many hard-working students, MUN has developed from a casual club to an upper division course to an award-winning team. I am very demanding and have extremely high expectations of my team members, who spend many hours every week in order to prepare for international conferences and, of course, to fundraise. Many of our students had never been on an airplane, or traveled outside of Colorado before their first model U.N. conference, yet they have competed and won against teams from elite universities from all over the world. I think it is a testament to Adams State that our students have the same opportunities afforded to students elsewhere.

Centeno's Model UN Team in Scotland

Centeno's model U.N. team in Scotland.

Q: How do you think your time at Arizona State University helped you prepare for your current position?

A: Arizona State gave me the opportunity to teach, so it is where I recognized that I wanted to be a teaching professor first and foremost. If my students are confident in their preparation when they graduate from Adams State, it is in large part because of the preparation I received at ASU. Maybe I should not admit this, but I did not fully realize how much I had learned until I started teaching, especially classes outside of my direct area of specialization. The feminist nature of my dissertation research meant that I was able to work with women’s studies faculty, which helped prepare me to take on the role of women’s and gender studies director at Adams State. As I’m sure is true of all faculty, I try to emulate my own professors. I owe Drs. Roxanne Doty, Michael Mitchell, Amy Lind and Richard Olson a great debt of gratitude. I try to pay it forward to my own students.

Q: What advice would you give to Latina students who wish to pursue a career in academia?

A: I am frequently asked this question, and I wish I had the magic words. Though the landscape is changing in academia, as Latinas, you are likely to be members of the “only” club:  the only Latina, and perhaps even the only woman. Learn from my mistakes. I rarely spoke in graduate courses and felt intimidated when I began my career as the only woman in my department at Adams State. 

Don’t take as long as I did to realize that it’s “OK to be a chingonaSpanish slang term for a strong woman; it has generally had negative connotations, but many in the Latinx community aim to "take back" the term..” This is my email signature quote, by Sandra Cisneros. It may not be the most professional language, but I hope it sends a message about challenging societal expectations. I think all marginalized groups have some familiarity with cultural code-switching, and in academia it’s no different.

Think about how you want to handle this. If you assimilate to advance your career, you might be accused of “selling out.” If you are vocal, you might think you are fulfilling the stereotype of “sassy” Latina. Don’t worry about that; you may well have to advocate for yourself, so speak up! Ironically (or maybe not), underrepresented groups in academia are often burdened with additional service to the university, such as extra committees, all in the name of greater representation. The trick is learning to say no to inordinate service demands without jeopardizing your career, especially if you are not tenured yet. I won’t pretend to have mastered this trick, but again, I encourage you to advocate for yourself and recognize the value of your time. 

I also suggest finding a Latina ally and/or mentor. I did not do this, but wish I had, especially earlier in my career. If there is no LatinX faculty organization where you are, do you have enough colleagues to create one? If not, contact those at other schools. Feel free to reach out to me! HACU (Hispanic Association of Colleges and Universities) conferences are also really great places to find support. I encourage you to also mentor students, not just Latino/a students. Doing so has helped ground me in my role as faculty. Working with students can also counter some of the prevailing negative images of Latina/os. Perhaps it should not be our responsibility to dispel myths, but for the time being it is our obligation so that future Latinas will not have to repeat history. 

Answers have been edited for length.

Matt Oxford

Manager of marketing and communications, School of Politics and Global Studies

480-727-9901

 
image title

Macedonian naming-rights dispute finds resolution after 25 years

June 14, 2018

Melikian Center director says the diplomatic process itself is a victory, but the agreement still faces some hurdles

Government leaders in Greece and the Republic of Macedonia have agreed on a resolution to their long-standing dispute over naming rights, striking a deal that will allow both countries use of the name “Macedonia.”

The new resolution rechristens the Republic of Macedonia as the Republic of North Macedonia, opening the way to entry into the European Union and NATO, which has been blocked until now by Greece, who previously laid exclusive claim to the name. Greece retains the name Macedonia, and the rich history associated with it, for its northern geographical region.

To gain further insight on this once-heated issue, ASU Now turned to Keith Brown, director of Arizona State University’s Melikian Center, who has been following this dispute for years.

Man in glasses and tie smiling

Keith Brown

Question: After 25 years, what brought leaders to reach a resolution?

Answer: For the first time since the Republic of Macedonia declared independence in 1992, both countries have governments that were elected for their opposition to rising, right-wing nationalism. Zoran Zaev and Alex Tsipras are both pragmatic politicians who are willing to defy accusations of national treachery. They want to fix relations between their two countries and commit to a shared European future, and are committed to getting it done.

Q: Did both sides get what they wanted in the new name? 

A: In so far as some factions on both sides wanted to monopolize the name, there is plenty of disappointment to go round. “North Macedonia” was an odd place to end, in that it explicitly suggests Macedonia has been subdivided. In other cases where there’s a geographic qualifierCountries such as North Korea, Northern Cyprus, Southern Sudan., it’s been the result of a war. In that regard, this is a win for everyone.

Q: Can the United States and the European Union claim some credit for this?

A: Matthew Nimetz, the U.S. negotiator, has been working on this process for almost a quarter century, for an annual salary of $1. It’s a victory for the idea that quiet persistence can work.

Q: Is this a done deal?

A: Both countries are democracies, with multiple checks and balances in place. The next hurdle in the Republic of Macedonia is posed by President (Gjorge) Ivanov, who owes his office to the now-disgraced nationalist VMRO-DPMNE party that escalated tensions with Greece for political profit. President Ivanov is threatening to use presidential veto power to torpedo the deal, arguing that it is unconstitutional. As a civil-society activist and scholar of political science before his election, he knew the dangers of populism, and he was part of the peaceful transition of Macedonia then. If he can channel his younger self and publicly endorse the deal, there’s a good chance the Republic can turn the page on a chapter of stubborn self-harm.

Q: What comes next, for the countries and the region?

A: If all goes as planned, the deal defuses Greek objections to its neighbor following its fellow former Yugoslav Republics into full membership in NATO and the European Union. Macedonian troops served in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the country became a candidate for EU accession back in 2005, the year before nationalists took power in Skopje. Polls have consistently indicated strong citizen support for the collective security and individual freedoms that EU membership promises. Textbooks and museums in both countries will need some updating, but hopefully those who cling to the imagined glories of the past can take joy in the gift they have the chance to hand to the next generation.

Erika Camacho represents ASU New College at STEM leadership training


June 12, 2018

Erika Camacho, associate professor in Arizona State University's School of Mathematical and Natural Sciences, in the New College of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences, represented ASU at the SACNAS – HHMI Advanced Leadership Institute to participate in advanced leadership training to increase STEM leaders of color. 

The SACNAS – HHMI Advanced Leadership Institute is led by Society for Advancement of Chicanos/Hispanics and Native Americans in Science (SACNAS) and the Howard Hughes Medical Institute (HHMI). Dr. Erika Camacho ASU Associate Professor Erika Camacho conducts research at the interface of mathematical applications to biology and sociology. Download Full Image

The institute, held June 4–7 at HHMI in Chevy Chase, Maryland, was an intensive advanced course for graduates of the Linton-Poodry SACNAS Leadership Institute (LPSLI). Participants tackled topics including: career success factors; increasing spheres of influence; challenges in organizational leadership; leading and managing policy initiatives; and decision making and team dynamics in executive teams.

HHMI is the ideal partner to help established leaders deepen their skills, said Rolando Madrid, SACNAS director of programs.

“HHMI has a strong legacy of supporting diversity, inclusion, mentoring and scientific excellence in the highest caliber of America’s STEM professionals,” he said.

Sonia Zárate, president-elect of SACNAS, said, “For 45 years, SACNAS has been a leader in diversifying the STEM enterprise. Like all challenges, changing the face of science to reflect current demographics requires a multipronged approach that includes training individuals and working to change the environment that the individuals are in. The SACNAS suite of leadership programs, which includes the LPSLI and the ALI, serve to empower participants as agents of change — the overall goal of these two programs being to prepare a cadre of diverse scientific leaders that will help drive diversity, equity and inclusion at all levels in their home institutions.”

Clifton Poodry, a founding member of SACNAS and co-founder with Marigold Linton of the LPSLI, said, “The scientific enterprise of the country, whether in academia, industry or government, benefits from the values and expertise embodied in the diverse membership of SACNAS. The LPSLI and ALI are designed to hone the skills of a group that will change the face of science.”

Camacho conducts research at the interface of mathematical applications to biology and sociology. Some of her projects include mathematically modeling the transcription network in yeast, the interactions of photoreceptors, social networks, and fungal resistance under selective pressure. She serves as co-director of the Applied Mathematical Sciences Summer Institute (AMSSI) and was co-principal investigator for two grants from the National Security Agency providing funding for the summer institute. Camacho has received various awards including a citation from the U.S. National Security Agency for her excellent work in mentoring and guiding undergraduate research. 

 
image title

ASU's second Pueblo Indian doctoral cohort puts community first

May 9, 2018

Indigenous doctoral graduates ready to make a difference after three years of intense study

Most people go to college to enhance their education, bolster their professional status and increase their earning power. But a doctoral cohort from New Mexico got their degrees to enrich their communities and build up their nation.

Meet the Arizona State University Pueblo Indian doctoral program Class of 2018.

“When our tribal leaders came to our orientation to give their blessing and a word of encouragement, they told us that we were about to embark on a spiritual journey,” said Doreen Bird, who received a doctorate from ASU’s School of Transformation this week after three years of hard work, research and sacrifice. “We realized at that point it wasn’t about us anymore. It’s about our communities.”

Bird is one of six people in the cohort, which saw its second class graduate on May 7.

Weeks before, Bird wore traditional Pueblo attire to her dissertation where she faced a roomful of Native American scholars.

“They were tough and challenged us every step of the way,” said Bird, who quit her job to finish her dissertation on Pueblo research methodologies. “I’m relieved it’s over but excited for the new journey that awaits all of us.”

Native American group photo

Pueblo cohort members Christina Castro, Porter Swentzell, Amanda Montoya (front), Peggy Bird (front), Rachell Tenorio and Doreen Bird pose for a portrait following the defense of their dissertations on ASU's Tempe campus on Thursday, April 12, 2018. Photo by Deanna Dent/ASU Now

The program was launched in 2012 as a partnership with New Mexico Pueblos to find solutions to complex issues facing their communities. The hope was for the graduates to be able to establish research agendas, engage in policymaking and enact strategies to address these challenges.

Built with the Leadership Institute at the Santa Fe Indian School, which is under the leadership of the 19 Pueblos of New Mexico, the program facilitates the training of practitioner-researcher-scholars within Pueblo communities.

The members of the cohort conducted their studies in New Mexico, creating a unique set of logistical opportunities. Coursework was conducted primarily through in-person courses with ASU-based faculty and focusing on issues of Pueblo peoples. These included Native health, education, families and communities. Their coursework also included international indigenous-community visits and concentrated training in indigenous research methodology and methods.

The program is led by School of Social Transformation faculty members Elizabeth Sumida Huaman, associate professor of indigenous education and a senior researcher with the Leadership Institute, and Bryan McKinley Jones Brayboy, President’s Professor, director of the Center of Indian Education and ASU’s special adviser to the president on American Indian Affairs.

“This program is a testament to what awesome results can be achieved from real collaboration with indigenous communities, which involves trust, creativity, and hard work,” Huaman said. “All of us who put this program together — the generations who produced the students, and the students themselves — exemplify this … this graduating cohort is the realization of our collective best hopes. They are intensely strong, intellectually and as researchers, and they are among the best people I know.”

Brayboy said Pueblos receiving their degrees is a monumental achievement; only one out of every 5,000 Native Americans and indigenous peoples in the U.S. who reach the ninth grade will go on to obtain a doctorate. He believes the achievement will help cohort members strengthen their pueblosThe term pueblo can also be used to describe the community, in addition to the people..

“I love this program, because it allows us to enact ASU’s vision that we work with tribal nations to create futures of their own making,” Brayboy said. “This process is exactly what self-determination looks like: tribal peoples doing work for their tribal communities. It’s an honor to be a part of the work.”

Amanda Montoya is a Taos Pueblo community planner and defended her thesis in April. Her work is focused on why educated people end up leaving their pueblos, otherwise known as “brain drain.”

“They might leave for a time but they always come back for cultural connections,” Montoya said. “I’ve discovered it’s not just a problem with pueblos but rural communities.”

Montoya said she experienced a brain drain of another kind in obtaining her degree.

“It was a huge sacrifice,” Montoya said. “The day I finished my dissertation, I took a deep breath and said, ‘I can be part of the world again!’”

The program was also a struggle for Christina Castro, whose grandfather Benjamin died on Feb. 6.

“I wasn’t sure I was going to make it. I was going to give up but then I thought, ‘My grandfather wouldn’t have wanted that for me,’” she said. “He was so proud that I was going to be the first doctorate in the family. I was coping with that loss, then gained strength from that loss.”

Peggy Bird, who is a pro tem judge in the Nambe and Taos pueblos, presented a powerful dissertation on Pueblo women’s voices, knowledge and resilience in the face of colonization, which she says still exists.

“We’re still dealing with colonization and different policies that are being imposed upon us,” said Bird. “But if you think about our survival, it’s amazing we’re still here … and we’re going to continue to be here.”

Porter Swentzell, a faculty member at the Institute of American Indian Arts, said there were moments of levity in those three intense years of study.

“One of the special things about this cohort is the humor we share,” said Swentzell, whose dissertation was on place-based education and sovereignty. “We have our own inside jokes. We spent a lot of time laughing, joking around, having a good time. All of that laughter is valuable in getting us to this point.”

June L. Lorenzo, a member of the 2015 cohort, attended last month’s dissertation defenses and was relieved to be an observer and not a presenter.

“It’s interesting to see how the energy of the first cohort has continued,” Lorenzo said. “I’m extremely proud of everyone.”

The cohort capped off the program with a visit to Canada in March for an academic exchange with indigenous health scholars at the University of Manitoba in Winnipeg. While there, the cohort competed in an Indigenous 3-Minute Thesis competition held at the University of Winnipeg where cohort members Rachell Tenorio and Doreen Bird took first and third place, respectively.

In addition to Swentzell, Montoya, Castro, Tenorio, and Doreen and Peggy Bird, there are five other Pueblo cohort members on a separate track set for graduation in the 2018–19 academic year.

The Pueblo Indian doctorate cohort receives support from The Leadership Institute at the Santa Fe Indian School, the W.K. Kellogg Foundation, and ASU’s School of Social Transformation in the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences.

 
image title

Cultural shift: ASU partners with LACMA to increase diversity in museum professionals

May 8, 2018

Master's fellowship to offer students mentorship, work opportunities in Los Angeles or at ASU Art Museum

Editor's note: This story is being highlighted in ASU Now's year in review. Read more top stories from 2018 here.

Arizona State University is partnering with the Los Angeles County Museum of Art on a new master’s fellowship designed to increase diversity among museum professionals.

The three-year program, called the LACMA-ASU Master’s Fellowship in Art History, will combine traditional master's-level coursework and a thesis with working 30 hours a week at LACMA or the ASU Art Museum, which is part of the Herberger Institute for Design and the Arts. The first-of-its-kind program will offer mentorship between students, curators and faculty and allow students to accelerate their careers. 

The new degree, to launch in August, was announced Tuesday in Phoenix where American Alliance of Museums was also holding its annual conference.

Steven Tepper, dean of the Herberger Institute, called the lack of diversity in museums a “cultural crisis.”

“We are not filling the leadership with the incredible, creative diversity of this country,” he said, noting that most diversity programs are for undergraduates but that the fellowship will be a way to fast-track people into leadership positions in the field.

LACMA Director and CEO Michael Govan said the partnership with ASU, which is committed to widening access, was a natural.

“We saw eye to eye very much about what we could do together to address some fairly large barriers to the future success and survival of art museums,” he said.

“The arts have been around for tens of thousands of years, museums for a couple hundred. It’s just a device we use to create access. So it’s no wonder that museums might be needing to change continuously.”

The first year will be a pilot program, starting with a handful of students drawn from people already affiliated with the two museums, Tepper said. Later this year, ASU and LACMA will decide how to accept future students.

The fellows, who must apply and be accepted by ASU, will travel back and forth between Los Angeles and Tempe several times a year, attending workshops and taking classes together through technology. The coursework will explore how museums can be more equitable and include a diverse range of voices and experiences. LACMA staff and Herberger faculty will offer a new course on curatorial and museum practice in the 21st century.

ASU President Michael M. Crow said that the fellowship is one of several programs that the university will undertake with LACMA, and he praised Govan for thinking innovatively.

“He thinks on a social scale. He thinks on a cultural scale, and he thinks about the transformation of society,” Crow said.

Miki Garcia, director of the ASU Art Museum, said that the partnership will allow ASU to have access to some of the collections from LACMA, making the art available to people in the Phoenix community who might never have the chance to travel to Los Angeles.

She said she took the job of director four months ago to be a part of reinventing the museum.

“I’m the product of a pipeline initiative and mentorship, and I wouldn’t be here without that,” she said.

“I’m keenly aware of what it’s like to walk into spaces where my stories aren’t being told and I don’t see myself on those walls, and we’ll change that at ASU.”

The Los Angeles County Museum of Art, founded in 1965, is the largest art museum in the Western United States, with a collection of more than 135,000 objects spanning 6,000 years of art history.

Top photo: LACMA Director and CEO Michael Govan (left) and ASU President Michael M. Crow address the crowd at the official launch of the LACMA-ASU Masters Fellowship in Art History on Tuesday evening at the A.E. England Building in downtown Phoenix. Photo by Jamie Ell/ASU Now

Mary Beth Faller

Reporter , ASU Now

480-727-4503

 
image title

'Soul sisters': Never too late to get degree

May 8, 2018

Members of Gila River Culture and Language Teacher Cohort support each other as they earn ASU master's degrees

In the 1950s, after the Indian Relocation Act was enacted, Priscilla Espinoza’s family moved from the Gila River Indian Community in the far southeast Valley to Southern California.

She met her husband, Phillip, there. They raised three sons. And they felt the sting of discrimination and racism that was commonplace to her people in those days. They became activists, joining the Brown Berets, a group modeled after the Black Panthers in the 1960s.

Espinoza was marching with them in Los Angeles during August 1970 when newspaper editor Ruben Salazar was killed. Salazar was struck by a tear-gas canister fired by a sheriff’s deputy.

“I was there, marching and dodging tear gas,” she said. “It really did make an impact, and a lot changed in Southern California. Because of that big march they started getting more minority teachers, and there was a big push for equal education.”

She put her own higher education, however, on the backburner. Through it all, she never forgot her place among the Akimel O’otham people in Arizona.

“I never lost my identity when I left,” Espinoza said. “I take it with me wherever I go.”

After Phillip, to whom she was married for 42 years, passed away seven years ago, the 69-year-old great-grandmother of two and grandmother of six felt a pull from home and a push from her late husband, who had told her to “keep going, keep living.”

“He was my greatest supporter,” she said.

Now she is among five women from the Gila River Indian Community who call themselves the “soul sisters.” Now, they are graduating grandmas and mothers — and remarkable role models for the people of their community and beyond.

Edwardine Thomas

“We incorporate the O’otham language in our visits because a lot of the parents do not know our language. So they learn along with their kids.” — Edwardine Thomas

Ranging in age from 36 to 69, Espinoza, Edwardine Thomas, Nina Allison, Marcella Hall and Starleen Somegustava have completed work on master's degrees in interdisciplinary studies as members of the Gila River Culture and Language Teacher Cohort, a partnership between Arizona State University’s Center for Indian Education and New College of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences, and the Gila River Indian Community Tribal Education Department. The first-of-its-kind program trains future teachers on their home reservation with a focus on tribal history and keeping alive the Akimel O’otham language.

The group has formed a tight bond.  

“We have all been through a lot of stuff together,” said Thomas, a 56-year-old grandmother of four. “These are my sisters. We’ve gone through a lot of stuff. We’re still going through a lot of stuff. Every week we come to class and we lean on each other.” 

All have experienced similar challenges while pursuing their education — from getting back into good study and attendance habits, to feeling a sense of responsibility for their immediate and extended families that is such an important piece of their culture, to balancing work and school, to solving the mysteries that are laptop computers and PowerPoint presentations.

Perhaps the greatest challenge was simply believing that, despite their age and responsibilities, they could achieve an advanced degree from ASU.

“I’ve been going to school off and on since 2014, starting at South Mountain (Community College), and I would say this year has been the most stressful year ever,” said Hall, 36, a cultural instructor for fifth- through eighth-grade students at Sacaton Middle School, about an hour south of Phoenix. She has a daughter and is caring for a niece and nephew.

“I’m handling it, and it’s hard,” she added. “Coming here and letting the ladies know and having their support, it gets easier.”

Espinoza and Thomas are the elders of the group. Each happened upon the cohort by happenstance.

“I always tell people I’m a lifelong learner,” Thomas said. “I’ve been going to school since after high school. I went to college for one year but had to drop out, just for family things. I had to take care of my siblings. So I had to work.”

She has worked for 26 years at the Blackwater Community School in Coolidge. When she attended an in-service teacher training program at the Wild Horse Pass Hotel and Casino, it led her back to school.

“There were people there from South Mountain (Community College), and they asked if any people were interested in obtaining their degrees,” she said. “So that’s where it started.”

Priscilla Espinoza

“I’m so proud of who I am and proud of what I represent to the people here. They trust me because they know I’m a member of the community, too. So my heart is full.” — Priscilla Espinoza

Now, she is the only member of her family to earn a college degree. Her work at Blackwater focuses on making home visits to people in the community and working with parents and children to reach child-development milestones in gross and fine motor skills and language.

“We incorporate the O’otham language in our visits because a lot of the parents do not know our language,” she said. “So they learn along with their kids.”

She said her ultimate goal is to establish a full-immersion school in the Gila River Indian Community that all of the soul sisters might someday work at.

To that end, the women will join forces this summer to bring together members of the community’s seven districts for a camp that would immerse participants in the O’otham language and culture. 

“We’re going to try to do it for three weeks and see how that goes,” Thomas said. “The rest of my cohort members are going to be in on that, too.

“It’s going to be limited to about 10 families per district, and hopefully this will be like a steppingstone for other people to come and join our group, because we’re open to anyone helping us — other community members that are fluent in language or dances or basket making.”

When Espinoza returned to the area to be near one of her sons living in Maricopa, she paid a visit to the Gila River Indian Community Governance Center to complete some paperwork. She and her husband had hoped to retire in the community.

“I had retired from a school district in California, where I was a special education (instructional assistant),” she said. “I was at the governance center to talk to a lady about my paperwork. I wasn’t looking for a job. This young lady was putting up flyers that said ‘special needs (teacher) urgently needed.’

“I said, ‘I used to do that for years.’ Long story short, they interviewed me that day, got my paperwork and hired me on the spot.”

She was asked to work with a young boy with cerebral palsy, who couldn’t walk or talk.

“He could only say ‘mama’ and ‘no,’ ” she said. “I put all my energy into this little boy. ... 

“I would see him every morning and say, ‘Good morning, what is your name? My name is Priscilla.’ I said that over and over for six months. One morning I said, ‘Hi, buddy,’ and he looked at me and said, ‘Hi, ’scilla!’ Oh my gosh, I knew then that this is it.”

Gregory Mendoza, who was Gila River Indian Community governor at the time, told her he had gotten a report about her work with the young boy, who now uses a walker.

“He said, ‘I want you to get into this program we have going on, this cohort. We want you to get your degree. We need people like you to help our people here.’ So that was it,” Espinoza said.

“I’m so proud of who I am and proud of what I represent to the people here. They trust me because they know I’m a member of the community, too. So my heart is full.”

The women in the cohort — many of whom are able to participate because of private giving — agree that they are motivated most by what they represent for their families and community members. Espinoza said the cohort members hope their successes will “snowball.”

“When family members see each one of us, the five of us, I think it will trickle down,” she said. “It will snowball, pick up momentum. That’s what we’re hoping for.”

Members of the Gila River Culture and Language Teacher Cohort

“I told myself I had to get back on track. You do it for your kids. You do it for your family. You’re that role model. You’re that example.” — Nina Allison (left, pictured with fellow cohort member Marcella Hall)

“I tell my students, ‘Don’t be a statistic,’” Hall added. “We have a lot of high school dropouts, and not many of our people are going to college. I say, ‘Make your people proud. Make your family proud of you. We need our people in our communities sitting in the seats we are in as teachers, as educators, as tribal council members. You are all going to be filling our seats.’”

Allison, a mother of four and grandmother of three, briefly stopped her studies in the program when a nephew was killed in a car accident. He had just graduated from high school. 

The desire to set an example for others kept her from giving up.

“I didn’t do homework. I didn’t do readings. That was a struggle for me,” she said. “... I told myself I had to get back on track. You do it for your kids. You do it for your family. You’re that role model. You’re that example.

“You have ups and downs and have struggles, but you go on.” 

Thomas tells young people to get their education while they’re young instead of waiting like the members of the cohort.

“If I could turn back time, I wish I would have stayed in school and finished (college) after high school,” she said. 

“(I tell them) ‘You can do it. Just set your priorities straight and know your family will always be behind you.’” 

The Akimel O’otham language

In 2009, the Gila River Indian Community adopted an orthography — a system of written words — for their Akimel O’otham language. Keeping that language alive is part of the mission of the Gila River Culture and Language Teacher Cohort. 

A sampling of words from the language:

  • Soith (pronounced: so yeth) — love
  • Sha pai masma (pronounced: sha pie masama) — How are you?
  • Sape (pronounced: saw pa) — fine
  • Tho epom ñei (pronounced: do umpam nyeh) — will see you again
  • Je’e (pronounced: j’uh) — mother
  • O:g (pronounced: awg) — father
  • Ga ga’a (pronounced: ga ga ah) — paternal grandmother
  • Lu lu’u (pronounced: luu luu ooh) — maternal grandmother
  • Vosk (pronounced: vawsk) — paternal grandfather
  • Ba ba’a (pronounced: ba ba’a) — maternal grandfather

Written by Bob Young; this story originally appeared in the summer issue of ASU Thrive magazine. Top photo: (From left) Priscilla Espinoza, Marcella Hall, Edwardine Thomas, Nina Allison and (not pictured) Starleen Somegustava have formed a close relationship through the Gila River program. Photos by Deanna Dent/ASU Now

 
image title

The journey continues: Central American caravan members reach the US

May 7, 2018

In wake of caravan seeking asylum, ASU transborder professor says it’s hard to gauge American sentiment on illegal immigration

The ordeal is finally over for a Central American caravan seeking asylum, with the last of the members crossing the U.S. border on Friday after a week of delays and heavy media attention.

The caravan, comprised of migrant men, women and children from mostly Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala, traveled approximately 2,000 miles from southern Mexico. They say they are escaping a life of violence, organized crime and immediate danger. Despite their reasons, the caravan of approximately 150 people were given a chilly reception at the U.S. port of entry near San Diego. They spent several nights in shelters, tents and makeshift camps, waiting to get processed.

President Donald Trump and the U.S. Department of Justice used the opportunity to send a tough-stance message to immigrants while advocates on the other side of the issue pushed hard for asylum. To gain a better understanding of this complex issue, ASU Now consulted Eileen Díaz McConnell, a professor in Arizona State University's School of Transborder Studies.

Woman with red hair smiling

Eileen Díaz McConnell

Question: A caravan of more than 150 people showed up at the U.S. border near San Diego seeking asylum in this country last week. What’s going on? 

Answer: Although many people see Mexico as solely the source of migrants, Mexico has long been a transit country that people from Honduras, El Salvador and elsewhere cross through to get to the United States, crossing Mexico on foot and on commercial trainsMcConnell says the train is called la bestia, or the beast, for that reason to get to the U.S. border. It is an extremely dangerous and long journey, with threat of injury or death from falling off a train that is not intended for passengers, [and threat of] sexual violence and exploitation from many bad actors including corrupt officials. These vulnerabilities are increased by the fact that these travelers are very far away from home and have few resources or networks on the trip. This is part of the reason why people might decide to travel in caravan, especially women and those with young children, to try to use safety in numbers to minimize the risk of assault, sexual violence, robberies, etc.  

A collective, Pueblo Sin Fronteras (Town Without Borders), has had a caravan like this for several years. Reporting suggests that several hundred are women and several hundred are children, most are from Honduras. Some of the people traveling in the caravan have asked for asylum in Mexico, while many are petitioning for asylum in the U.S. based on gang violence, organized crime, corruption, government-sponsored violence and repression. Most Central Americans who petition for asylum are denied. 

Q: Why has their entry taken so long to process and will they be allowed entry into this country? 

A: The process of petitioning for asylum takes a long time involving multiple federal agencies, interviewing and screening, and going before a judge to make a case that the requirements of asylum have been met. About 70 percent or more [of] people petitioning for asylum from Mexico, El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala who have legal representation are denied and denial rates are even higher for those who don’t have legal representation.

Cuban immigrants have been a prioriRelating to or derived by reasoning from self-evident propositions — presupposed by experience. categorized as refugees deserving of protection, although the "wet foot, dry foot policy" was ended in January 2017. The U.S. government has not categorized immigrants from other countries as meriting the same treatment even though they might have a reasonable fear of persecution or harm. Many migrants traveling in the caravan could meet the requirementsTo qualify for asylum, you must establish that you are a refugee who is unable or unwilling to return to his or her country of nationality, or last habitual residence if you have no nationality, because of persecution or a well-founded fear of persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. Source: U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (https://www.uscis.gov/i-589). for asylum, either themselves personally or family members experiencing threats or harm in the past and having credible fears of harm if returned to their home countries. However, it’s also clear that judges’ decisions about who meets requirements for asylum are influenced by legal representation and factors that go beyond the specific petitioner, otherwise, there likely wouldn’t be such drastic differences in denial rates across countries.

Q: What are some historical reasons why immigrants flee their native countries to come to the United States?

A: As I begin, it’s important to emphasize that only about 4 percent of the world’s population actually leave their home country for another country, so the reasons that people leave must be incredibly strong.

People leave home countries and come to the U.S. for many reasons. Migration scholars emphasize both factors that push people out of their home country and factors pulling them to another country; and the combination of push and pull factors differ across countries, even within the same region. In the case of those leaving El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala, push factors include decades of very high levels of violence. These countries have experienced long and violent civil wars and cities in these countries have some of the highest homicide rates in the world. It has been difficult to recover from hurricanes, floods and other disasters that have wiped out homes, roads, crops, and greatly affected agriculture and other industries. There are high poverty rates and unemployment rates. Governments in these countries have not only sponsored violence, but have not been able to resolve these long-standing problems that push people out. At the height of civil wars in countries like El Salvador and Honduras, emigrants sought political asylum in the United States, which means that people in El Salvador, Guatemala [and] Honduras may have family members who have been in the U.S. for decades. These social networks already in the U.S., coupled with work opportunities and a higher economic standard of living, help pull political refugees and economic migrants to the United States.

Q: Attorney General Jeff Sessions recently said, “When respect for the rule of law diminishes, so too does our ability to protect our great nation, its borders, and its citizens.” That seems to encapsulate the sentiment of many Americans regarding illegal immigration. What is it that most people do not understand or see regarding this situation?

A: In my view, it is difficult to know for sure whether Americans agree with this statement (that declines in rule of law affect ability to protect the nation) or whether Americans believe that this particular caravan of migrants at the border formally seeking entry into the U.S. is not respecting the rule of law. This particular caravan of migrants from Central America are trying to regularize their status and ask for asylum by presenting themselves at the border for admission, they are not trying to enter without formal authorization or overstay visas. That some migrants seeking admission may have been in the U.S. previously without legal status or after a stay of deportation does not necessarily suggest that the same people do not respect the rule of law. The reasons why people remain in the U.S. without legal status are complex and misunderstood. …

Regarding American sentiments about “illegal immigration” — with respect to immigrants in the U.S. without documentation (migration scholars tend to use terms like unauthorized or undocumented rather than illegal) — Americans are relatively divided in views about undocumented immigrants generally, especially by whether the respondents are Republicans, Democrats or Independents. And there is quite a bit of variation in public opinion about what the federal government should do about undocumented migration.

On the other hand, polls results actually suggest that Americans are increasingly positive about immigrants overall as constituting a strength rather than a burden to our country, compared to the 1990s. They are also pretty positive about groups such as undocumented youth finding a way to remain in the U.S. and the majority oppose the construction of a wall on the Southern border.

Seeing a need, graduating senior Kaitlyn Felix studied Spanish to be a better doctor


May 4, 2018

Editor’s note: This is part of a series of profiles for spring 2018 commencement

Graduating senior Kaitlyn Felix dreams of becoming a surgeon someday. To help her achieve that goal, however, she didn’t just study health sciences. She studied Spanish at the School of International Letters and Cultures. Kaitlyn Felix Graduating senior Kaitlyn Felix wants to be a surgeon someday, but uses Spanish to help her connect with patients. Download Full Image

“I’ve been a CNA (Certified Nursing Assistant) since high school,” Felix said. “A lot non-English speakers are your patients. It’s great to have a medical background and a Spanish background. I’ve taken two or three classes that had a Spanish medical language frame.”

Felix has substantial experience in both medicine and Spanish. Spanish is her first language and the language her family speaks at home. Besides working as CNA, she interned with a pediatric surgeon last summer and was her grandfather’s caregiver while he battled cancer and dementia.

Blending the two disciplines made Felix better at both, and prepared her to work, research, study and succeed at ASU.  

“It’s almost like learning another language. Learning the body parts, the tools, the correct way to form a question to a patient. It’s been really interesting and helpful to me as I worked through the medical field all through college,” Felix said.

She has found that speaking Spanish has been especially helpful while practicing medicine in the Southwest, enabling her to connect directly with patients, as opposed to always need a translator. That connection leads to trust, especially dealing with pediatrics.

“It was nice to have to have that language barrier be broken. Obviously they’re there for kind of a scary situation. It was with family, obviously with children most of the time,” Felix recalled. “Their face would light up, like ‘Oh my God, someone speaks Spanish here. That’s great; I’ll know what’s going on.’”

At SILC, as she balanced her health science studies and Spanish minor, she found the faculty responsive, enthusiastic and supportive. She said that all SILC staff “really take the time to get to know their students … they actually seem to care about their work.”

Now applying to medical school, Felix wants a program that gives back to underserved communities. She has found her cultural competence to be a professional benefit and wants a program that expands on it.

“Cultural competency is a big thing where we’re seeing problems in the medical field,” Felix said. “Understanding culture, understanding language barriers … it might increase lifestyle and medical advice. I think it’s important to be interdisciplinary … every case is different.”

SILC advisers would help Felix plan out her semesters. This meant focusing on medical classes at one point, then getting ahead in language classes when she had class openings. Felix accomplished all this while also holding down a job.

Felix said that while balancing the two programs was challenging, she succeeded by reminding herself that she was not just working, but working toward something.

“There’d be late nights, super early mornings, lack of sleep, lack of food, but it’s one more day closer to medical school, one more day closer to becoming a doctor, one more day closer to graduation. And graduation is a week from now,” Felix said. “So I made it.”

Gabriel Sandler

Political science student receives Roberto L. Pastor student award


May 3, 2018

Vasthy Lamadrid, a student majoring in political science at Arizona State University, was recently awarded the Roberto L. Pastor Student Award. This honor is meant to recognize a student who engages in “outreach to Chicano/Latino youth.”

Lamadrid kindly took some time to answer questions regarding her work and the award: Vasthy Lamadrid, a student majoring in political science, will be a sixth-grade teacher at Sheely Farms Elementary School after graduation. Download Full Image

Question: What has been your involvement with ASU and the surrounding community?

Answer: I am an undocumented student here at ASU. As such, I have felt tremendously lucky to have an opportunity to attend a four-year institution knowing that many undocumented students across the state are unable to do so due to financial restraints and limited resources.

For the past three years, I have been a student worker at DREAMzone, which is a resource at Arizona State University for our undocumented, DACA and students with families of mixed immigration status. One of those resources includes a training for ASU students, faculty and staff with a goal to increase institutional awareness and support.

However, I felt that I needed to do more. Thankfully, I was able to meet other students on campus who shared my passion for helping students and together we co-founded Undocumented Students for Education Equity (USEE) at ASU. This organization has really been at the forefront of the tuition fight for DACA recipients here in the state. We have been able to not only bring undocumented students and allies together, but we have also served as a resource providing important legal updates and provide resources for students.

Last semester, I was also awarded the Wells Fargo Transborder Latina Studies Research Scholarship. I have spent this semester going into my community and documenting stories of undocumented families in hopes to humanize, bring to light the injustices that they face and misconceptions, and the many ways that the immigration system in the U.S is broken. This project will culminate in a documentary that will be presented in the community at the end of the semester.

While I have a personal investment in this project as both my parents are undocumented, I think that it is already critical to preserve history.

Q: What has been your involvement in terms of outreach to Hispanic youth?

A: As a Latina, undocumented and first-generation college student, I have aimed to involve myself in opportunities that will give back to my community. While my focus has definitely been in the immigrant community, I care about justice for all. For this reason, I became passionate about education. Throughout my time here at ASU, I have had the pleasure of interning twice at local public high schools, and worked as a researcher for CompuGirls, which was a program designed for Hispanic young girls in underserved districts to learn latest technology while empowering them as change agents. USEE also works doing outreach to Hispanic youth to ensure that they are aware of the resources, (and to) invite them to join our advocacy efforts with the aim to ensure that they too could pursue their dreams.

Q: What was your reaction to winning this award?

A: I was thankful and happy.

Q: What are your plans postgraduation?

A: I am passionate about social justice for my community and any other marginalized group of people that do not have equitable access to opportunities and resources. There are many ways to contribute to this fight. I, however, have felt a deep calling for education. I just accepted a job as a sixth-grade teacher at Sheely Farms Elementary School in the Valley.

While I am committed to be the best teacher I can be in the classroom every day, I know the importance of being civically engaged and the importance of advocacy to create profound changes in society through legislation.

On a more personal and less professional level, I hope to continue learning Italian and advocate for an immigration reform so that I can go back to Italy and also Mexico to visit my family.

office assistant, School of Politics and Global Studies

Pages