Breaking the final barrier: room-temperature electrically powered nanolasers

March 11, 2013

A breakthrough in nanolaser technology has been made by Arizona State University researchers.

Electrically powered nano-scale lasers have been able to operate effectively only in cold temperatures. Researchers in the field have been striving to enable them to perform reliably at room temperature, a step that would pave the way for their use in a variety of practical applications. Ning nanolaser research Download Full Image

Details of how ASU researchers made that leap are published in a recent issue of the research journal Optics Express (Vol. 21, No. 4,  4728 2013). Read the full article.

The research team is led by Cun-Zheng Ning, an electrical engineering professor in the School of Electrical, Computer and Energy Engineering, one of ASU’s Ira A. Fulton Schools of Engineering.

He has been among engineers and scientists across the world attempting to fabricate a workable nanolaser with a volume smaller than its wavelength cubed – an intermediate step toward further miniaturization of lasers.

Miniaturizing lasers is crucial to making electronics smaller and better, and enabling them to operate faster. Packing more lasers into smaller spaces is necessary for downsized devices to maintain high performance. Being able to integrate more lasers onto a small microchip would make the next generations of computers faster and smaller. The wavelength scale is the next milestone to be achieved in the overall effort to enable more miniaturization.

Refining the shrinking technique

Ning explains that extremely small and thin lasers have been developed, but they needed to be optically driven by a larger laser. In addition, current electrically driven nanolasers can operate only at low temperatures or and emit light only in short bursts or pulses.

To enable them to be useful in practical applications – particularly for improvements of electronic and photonic technologies – it’s necessary that the laser operates at room temperature without a refrigeration system, that it be powered by a simple battery instead of by another laser, and that it is able to emit light continuously.

“That has been the ultimate goal in the nanolaser research community,” Ning says.

Ning’s team started looking for solutions almost seven years ago, before he joined ASU, with his then- postdoctoral assistant, Alex Maslov, who is currently a scientist with Canon USA Inc.

While working for the National Aeronautics and Space Administration’s Ames Research Center, they proposed a semiconductor wire coated with a silver shell. They showed that such a core-shell structure was able to shrink the nanolaser to an incredibly small scale.

About four years ago, working with Martin Hill, a former professor at Eindhoven University of Technology in the Netherlands, the team developed the thinnest nanolaser capable of operating at low temperatures. Two years ago, with the aid of Ning’s student, Kang Ding, they were able to raise the operating temperature to 260 Kelvin (8.33 degrees Fahrenheit).

Significant impacts

More recently the team demonstrated a device that could operate at room temperature (read the article in the journal Physical Review B), but the overheating  led to imperfect device operation  and a conclusive demonstration of lasing remained elusive.

The most recent results, however, demonstrated an eight-fold improvement over previous results from a year ago, finally providing an unambiguous demonstration of continuous electrically driven operation of a laser at room temperature, Ning says.

To explain the significance of such an advance, Ning says, “Imagine if computers had to be cooled down to minus 200 Celsius (minus 350 degrees Fahrenheit) for our current information technology to work. If that were the case, we would not have the widespread usage of computers and social media.”

With nanolasers that can operate at room temperature and be powered by a simple battery, they can be used to make computers operate faster, significantly broaden Internet bandwidth, and provide light sources for many computer-chip-based sensing and detection technologies.

Show-stopping advance

But the benefits of achieving continuous room temperature operation go beyond the practical aspects, Ning says.

“In terms of fundamental science, it shows for the first time that metal heating loss is not an insurmountable barrier for room-temperature operation of a metallic cavity nanolaser under electrical injection. For a long time, many doubted if such operation is even possible at all,” he says.

“Unlike nanolasers driven by another laser, where the driving laser can be chosen so that the heat generation is minimized, electrical injection by a battery produces more heat. In addition, typical metals can be heated quickly by the operation of the nanolasers. Thus, such elevated heat generation has been perceived as a show-stopper for such nanolasers,” Ning says.

He adds: “More importantly, similar metal semiconductor structures used for nanolasers are also currently being explored for many other applications, such as being a building block for the formation of artificial materials that have remarkable properties. This demonstration is thus also important to the researchers working in those areas of materials science and engineering.”

Crediting collaborators

The breakthrough by Ning’s team required skillful nanofabrication and measurements. Credit for that contribution to the research goes to several of his students, primarily Kang Ding, Leijun Yin, and Zhicheng Liu. Yin is pursuing his doctorate in physics. Ding and Liu are pursuing doctoral degrees in electrical engineering.

“It is extremely challenging to get everything correct at the nanometer scale. At such a small scale, any fabrication error becomes relatively large, and there are many fabrication steps, each of which is rather complex,” he says.

The team also benefited greatly from long-term collaboration with Martin Hill and his colleagues who provided technical support, especially Meint Smit, a professor of electrical engineering at Eindhoven University of Technology, who allowed the use of the university’s advanced fabrication facility during the final phase of the research.

The research has been supported by the Defense Advanced Project Agency (an agency of the U.S. Department of Defense), and by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research.

Ning points to several managers at the agencies – including Henryk Temkin, Michael Haney, Scott Rodgers, Michael Gerhold, and Gernot Pomrenke – who were willing to support the project despite skepticism.

Remaining challenges

“Many experts questioned the feasibility of such a project and doubted if we would ever be able to make such a small laser, let alone one that worked at room temperature,” he says. “But we were convinced of the novelty and significance of such a project. With the support and trust of these agencies, we were eventually able to achieve or exceed many of our initial goals. “

Ning says many challenges remain in efforts to integrate nanolasers into a photonic system on-chip platform, as well as to prolong the lifetime of laser operation, and to further develop the capabilities of such devices. In addition, the physical mechanisms involved in the interaction of photons with metallic structures on small scale are not yet fully understood, so there is still much research to be done in this area.

“But thanks to the realization of room-temperature operation of nanolasers, all these goals can start to be more effectively explored,” Ning says.

Joe Kullman

Science writer, Ira A. Fulton Schools of Engineering


ASU among best in U.S. News & World Report’s graduate schools rankings

March 12, 2013

Arizona State University ranks among the best schools in the nation for graduate programs, according to the U.S. News & World Report 2014 edition of “America’s Best Graduate Schools” which lists a number of programs in the top tier.

Among the areas that ASU placed in the rankings are: Download Full Image

• Among online graduate business degree programs, ASU ranked No. 2 overall. The W. P. Carey School of Business is ranked No. 6 in the nation in supply chain/logistics, No. 22 for its part-time MBA program and No. 30 among the nation’s top business schools. The school also was No. 36 for its doctoral program in economics.

• ASU was No. 2 for its city management and urban policy graduate program, and public affairs master's programs at ASU are ranked No. 16 overall.

• ASU’s doctoral program in criminology is No. 12 overall.

• Education programs overall are at No. 24 in the country for graduate programs.

• In the health disciplines, ASU’s audiology doctoral program ranked No. 17 and the speech-language pathology master’s program ranked No. 21.

• The Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law was No. 5 in legal writing. Overall, the school is No. 29 among top schools for graduate programs.

• Among specialties, ASU is ranked No. 17 for the earth sciences doctoral program.

• ASU placed No. 21 for its master's programs in nursing.

• ASU ranked No. 22 overall for its Master of Fine Arts program in art, No. 5 for printmaking, seventh for ceramics and 11th for photography graduate programs.

• Engineering at ASU came in at No. 44 overall among graduate programs in the nation.

• The psychology doctoral program at ASU ranked No. 38 overall.

For the sixth year in a row, the W. P. Carey School of Business at ASU ranks in the top 30 among the best graduate business schools in the nation. The school’s online MBA program at No. 2 among online graduate business programs is known for its flexibility, convenience and stellar faculty. The new list ranks the school No. 30 for its full-time MBA program, the best ranking for any Arizona school for its full-time MBA program.

Mary Lou Fulton Teachers College at Arizona State University continues its climb in the rankings of the nation’s highest-rated graduate programs in education at No. 14 among public graduate schools of education and 24th among all public and private graduate programs in the field. Last year ASU’s graduate education programs ranked 16th and 26th, respectively.

The Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law at Arizona State University continues its success among the nation’s leading law schools at No. 29. The College of Law’s Legal Method and Writing Program ranks No. 5 among all law schools and reflects the school’s effort and resources devoted to the program with eight full-time faculty with more than 70 years of combined teaching experience and myriad courses that are offered.

The publication’s ranking of ASU’s earth sciences program in the College of LIberal Arts and Sciences as 17th among public and private graduate programs, makes it among the top 10 universities in the western United States. More than 100 earth sciences graduate programs were surveyed. This year, two out of four specialty earth science programs were ranked in the top 20 in the nation. These include geochemistry (ranked 16th) and geology (ranked 17th).