ASU engineer makes strides in sustainable computing

March 26, 2015

Arizona State University computer scientist Carole-Jean Wu is gaining attention for her work to improve the energy efficiency of both large- and small-scale computing nodes – encompassing everything from desktop processors, smartphones and other mobile devices to business-scale data centers.

Wu’s paper, “Architectural Thermal Energy Harvesting Opportunities for Sustainable Computing,” recently received the Best of Computer Architecture Letters (CAL) award. CAL is a semi-annual Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) forum for publication of technical papers about new, high-quality ideas in computer architecture. Carole-Jean Wu computer architecture Download Full Image

The award gave her the opportunity to present her line of research on energy harvesting at the 21st IEEE Symposium on High Performance Computer Architecture in San Francisco in February.

Wu is an assistant professor of computer science and engineering in the School of Computing, Informatics, and Decision Systems Engineering, one of ASU’s Ira A. Fulton Schools of Engineering. She also holds an affiliated faculty appointment in the School of Electrical, Computer and Energy Engineering.

Her research focuses on designs for chip-multiprocessors and heterogeneous computing systems, energy-efficient smartphone architecture and architectural energy harvesting techniques for modern computing nodes.

Her prize-winning CAL paper focuses on a cutting-edge method for removing heat in a computer’s central processing unit (CPU).

Harvesting heat

In a typical computer system, a large amount of heat is generated as the processor performs computations. But even with the use of fan-based cooling mechanisms, chip temperature at the transistor junction in computer systems can easily exceed 100 degrees Celsius (212 F), which is high enough to harm computer circuitry.

To control the temperature of the processor in the presence of chip-wide, fan-based cooling, current technology activates a built-in system called the “dynamic thermal management unit” to throttle down the processor operating frequency so that the rate of heat generation is slowed. But when the unit kicks in, a computer’s performance suffers because computation is slowed down to prevent overheating.

When slowing down computational power doesn’t work sufficiently, a computer will automatically shut off to prevent damage to the CPU. (If you’re an avid computer gamer, you’ve probably experienced this.)

Rather than allowing this superfluous heat to reduce performance speed, Wu decided to harvest it with a thermoelectric generator – a device that converts heat to electricity using a phenomenon called the Seebeck effect.

“A temperature difference in the thermoelectric module creates an electric voltage differential, thereby generating electricity,” she explained.

Computer cooling techniques

She proposed in her research paper that by placing the thermoelectric module between the processor and heat sink in the computer, as much as 1 watt of power could be harvested with commercially available thermoelectric generators.

The question concerning this method is whether that is the most efficient placement of the module.

“This is where computer architecture comes in,” Wu said.

Because the module will introduce a non-negligible thermal resistance in the computer's central processing unit, it is not advisable to place thermoelectric generators in any chip locations without care, she said. Chips in locations operating at above 75 degrees Celsius (167 F) will likely rise to more than 100 degrees Celsius in the presence of the thermoelectric modules.

Wu’s work concluded that the most optimal location for the thermoelectric generator is a place in the processor where the operating temperature is 60 degree Celsius or below, which is typically the cache memory modules of a processor.

In another of her research papers – “Hot Spot Cooling and Harvesting CPU Waste Heat using Thermoelectric Modules” in Proceedings of the International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition Conference – Wu reported on her investigations to find the best possible arrangement of the thermoelectric modules over computer processors.

She collaborated on the project – and the research paper – with ASU mechanical engineering professor Patrick Phelan and engineering doctoral student Soochan Lee.

They are looking at using the combination of thermoelectric generators and thermoelectric coolers at the processor, harvesting processor waste heat with the thermoelectric generators and powering the thermoelectric coolers with the harvested energy for what is called “spot cooling.”

Thermoelectric coolers work the same way as a thermoelectric generator, except in reverse: When experiencing a voltage differential, the cooler will create a temperature differential (called the Peltier effect) in the processor, and thereby lower the temperature of the CPU. The team is now working on a prototype design for modern processors.

Energy-saving impacts

Wu said the new method opens up possibilities for optimal fan and dynamic processor voltage and frequency controls that could significantly reduce the power consumption of processors of all kinds, large or small.

The projected power savings for major data centers – which can be comprised of hundreds of thousands of server processors (Google, for example, uses about 900,000 servers) – is about 50 percent, translating into a significant amount of savings in the nation’s electricity consumption.

Wu predicts that on a smaller scale, the prototype can reduce the cooling cost of individual processors by as much as 20 percent.

Wu has worked as an intern with Intel, IBM and Google. She was among recipients of the 2013 Bisgrove Early Career Award given by Science Foundation of Arizona and the 2011-2012 Intel Ph.D. Fellowship Award.

Her research is being supported in part by Science Foundation Arizona through the Bisgrove award and by the National Science Foundation.

Wu earned doctoral and master’s degrees in electric engineering from Princeton University and a bachelor’s of science degree in electrical and computer engineering from Cornell University.

Written by Jiaqi Wu and Joe Kullman

Joe Kullman

Science writer, Ira A. Fulton Schools of Engineering


ASU debaters go the distance in national tournament

March 26, 2015

Arizona State University seniors Peter Chotras and Rohit Rajat made it to the sweet 16 in the Cross Examination Debate Association Nationals Tournament – a feat unmatched by any ASU student since 2000.

The tournament was held March 19-23 at Wichita State University. The Cross Examination Debate Association (CEDA) is the largest intercollegiate policy debate association in the United States. two students holding a plaque Download Full Image

The tournament hosted more than 50 schools from around the country and consisted of 116 two-person teams that debated a 2014-2015 topic: The United States should legalize all or nearly all of one or more of the following: marijuana, prostitution, online gambling, the sale of human organs and physician assisted suicide.

Of those 116 teams, only 43 earned winning records to advance to the elimination rounds.

“I am really proud of what they have done so far, they’ve worked really hard,” said Izak Dunn, assistant director of debate at ASU. “So seeing that pay off in terms of wins and success and recognition is really satisfying because they deserve it.”

Rajan and Chotras also each received the CEDA National Debate Scholar Award during the tournament's award ceremony. The Summa Cum Laude award recognized debaters with the highest possible academic records: 3.75-4.00 GPA.

The two ASU seniors debated their way into the elimination round of the tournament, making it through the preliminary rounds with a record of 6-2 that included victories over UNLV and Dartmouth College. By virtue of their record, Chotras and Rajan were the 11th seed for the elimination bracket, and were able to bypass the round of 64, before competing in the round of 32 teams. In that debate, they defeated a team from Central Oklahoma in order to advance to the Sweet 16.

“One thing that is so great working with Peter and Rohit is that they use every opportunity they can to get better,” Dunn said. “From round one of the first debate of the year all the way to the last one, they are always using it to get better.”

The CEDA National Tournament is not the last stop for these seniors. They will represent ASU at the National Debate Tournament, April 3-6, at the University of Iowa, after placing first at their district-qualifying tournament by winning 7 out of 8 debates against other National Debate Tournament hopefuls from the Arizona/California/Nevada region.

The two seniors will compete against 77 other teams from across the country, including Harvard, Northwestern and Cal Berkeley. Unlike CEDA, which has an open-entry format, teams must qualify to be invited to compete at the National Debate Tournament. 

“Peter and Rohit have debated for ASU for four years. They embody everything we try to instill in our students: hard work, perseverance, and leadership. Their performance at CEDA positions them to perform well at the National Debate Tournament,” said Adam Symonds, ASU director of forensics (speech and debate).